The Indian Leadership Paradox: Why Technical Experts Struggle to Inspire

As someone who was born in Indian and raised in Canada and someone who's spent 30 years working with global clients,  I've had the privilege of observing leadership styles from around the world. But there's one thing that still puzzles me: why Indian leaders, despite their business and technical expertise, often struggle to inspire and motivate their teams.

I've spoken to many Indians, and I've got to be honest, I've never come across anyone who truly inspires me. Don't get me wrong, I have immense respect for their technical and business skills, but when it comes to leadership, there's something missing.

I should make a correction, there are two individuals whom I do have respect for. They, like me, were not only born in India, but spent a considerable time in North America where they honed their professional and leadership skills. Skills I will list below:

  • Leadership Characteristics: Being Accessible | Being an Active Listener | Being Adaptable | Being Accountable | Being Assertive | Being Attentive | Being Authentic | Demonstrating Business Acumen | Being Charismatic | Being Collaborative | Communicating | Resolving Conflicts | Continuously Learning | Being Courageous | Being Creative | Thinking Critically | Demonstrating Cultural Competence | Being Curious | Being Customer-Obsessed | Being Decisive| Leveraging Domain Experience | Being Empathetic | Being Employee-Obsessed | Demonstrating Emotional Intelligence | Empowering Others | Being Ethical | Providing Feedback | Being Flexible | Focusing | Setting High Standards | Practicing Humility | Being Inclusive | Being Innovative | Being Inspirational | Being Optimistic | Being Passionate | Developing People | Solving Problems | Reflecting | Building Relationships | Being Respectful | Taking Risks | Rolling Up Sleeves | Practicing Self-Awareness | Practicing Self-Care | Demonstrating Servant Leadership | Being Strategic Strategic | Being Supportive | Being Technically Astute | Managing Time | Being Transparent | Being Trustworthy | Being Visionary

The Technical Expertise Trap

Indian leaders are often masters of their craft, with a deep understanding of complex systems and processes. But when it comes to leading teams, they often fall short. Why is that? Is it because they're so focused on technical expertise that they forget about the human side of leadership?

Cultural Baggage

Let's face it, Indian culture places a strong emphasis on respect for authority, hierarchy, and tradition. While these values have their benefits, they can also lead to a reluctance to challenge or question leaders, stifling open communication and collaboration. The result? Leaders who are more focused on maintaining their position and authority rather than developing their teams.

Emotional Intelligence: The Missing Link

Emotional intelligence is what sets great leaders apart from good ones. It's the ability to understand and manage your own emotions, as well as those of your team members. But in India, emotional intelligence often takes a backseat to technical expertise. The result? Leaders who struggle to build strong relationships with their teams and create a positive work environment.

Hierarchical Organizational Structures: The Roadblock to Innovation

Many Indian organizations, particularly in the public sector, are stuck in hierarchical structures that stifle innovation, creativity, and empowerment. This leads to leaders who are more focused on maintaining the status quo rather than developing their teams and driving growth.

The Diversity and Inclusion Deficit

Indian organizations often lack diversity and inclusion, leading to a lack of diverse perspectives and ideas. This results in leaders who are not equipped to manage and motivate teams with diverse backgrounds and needs.

The Education and Training Gap

Leadership development programs and training initiatives are not as prevalent or effective in India as they are in other countries. This means that Indian leaders may not have access to the same level of training and development opportunities as their global counterparts.

It's Time for Change

So, what's the way forward? It's time for Indian leaders to take a hard look in the mirror and acknowledge the areas where they need to improve. It's time for organizations to invest in leadership development programs that focus on emotional intelligence, diversity, and inclusion. And it's time for us to create a culture that values empowerment, collaboration, and innovation.

The future of Indian leadership is bright, but it requires us to confront the paradox head-on and take bold action. Are you ready to rise to the challenge?

‍