‍

In the world of IT service management, understanding the difference between incidents and service requests is critical for delivering consistent and effective support. Though both terms are used regularly, they serve very distinct purposes in ITIL, the industry framework for service management. Misclassifying them can lead to inefficiencies, longer resolution times, and confusion among both IT teams and users.

So, what exactly is the difference between an incident and a service request? Let’s dive deeper into each.

What is an Incident?

In ITIL, an incident is defined as an unplanned interruption to a service or a reduction in the quality of a service. The primary objective in incident management is to restore normal service operation as quickly as possible and minimize the impact on business operations.

Here are some examples of incidents:

  • A company’s email system suddenly goes down.
  • An employee’s computer crashes, preventing them from accessing critical applications.
  • A network outage that affects multiple users or departments.

The focus of incident management is restoring service. It involves troubleshooting and resolving issues that arise unexpectedly, often requiring urgency, depending on the severity of the impact.

Incident Characteristics:
  • Unplanned event: Something that wasn’t supposed to happen.
  • Service interruption: Affects the availability or quality of a service.
  • Restoration-focused: The goal is to bring things back to normal as quickly as possible.

What is a Service Request?

A service request is a formal request from a user for something to be provided—whether that’s access to a service, information, or even a standard change. Service requests are not tied to service failures or unplanned interruptions. Instead, they are routine and often involve repeatable, well-defined procedures.

Examples of service requests include:

  • A user requests a new laptop.
  • A password reset request.
  • Requesting access to a specific software or system.
  • Changing user permissions or roles.

Unlike incidents, service requests don’t indicate something is wrong; they represent a need or desire for something additional. They are handled through established processes that typically do not require urgent attention.

Service Request Characteristics:
  • Planned activity: It’s part of routine service delivery.
  • No service interruption: The system or service is still available.
  • Fulfillment-focused: The goal is to provide the user with what they requested.

Why the Distinction Matters

While incidents and service requests may appear similar on the surface (both involve user issues or needs), the distinction is essential for several reasons:

  1. Process Efficiency: Incidents are usually urgent and need immediate resolution to prevent or minimize downtime. Service requests, on the other hand, can follow a standardized, well-documented process. Mixing these can overload the incident management team with tasks that don’t require immediate attention.
  2. Resource Allocation: Incident management often requires specialized skills, faster response times, and a focus on problem-solving. Service request management can be automated or delegated to lower-level support staff since it involves predefined tasks that are easier to execute.
  3. Prioritization: In ITIL, incidents are typically prioritized based on impact and urgency, whereas service requests are usually handled in the order they are received. By misclassifying incidents as service requests or vice versa, organizations risk misallocating their resources, leading to longer downtimes or delays in fulfilling user needs.
  4. Tracking and Reporting: Metrics for incidents focus on time-to-restore service, root cause analysis, and preventing future incidents. Metrics for service requests focus on fulfillment times, user satisfaction, and consistency. Without a clear distinction, it becomes difficult to measure and improve both processes.

Common Misunderstandings

One of the most common areas of confusion is the password reset scenario. Is it an incident or a service request?

In most cases, password resets are service requests. They’re routine tasks that happen regularly and are part of normal service operations. However, if a system failure prevents users from resetting their passwords (for example, a password reset tool or server is down), that could be classified as an incident because it represents an unplanned interruption to a service.

How ITIL Helps Define and Manage These Processes

ITIL provides a structured approach to distinguish between incidents and service requests, allowing organizations to streamline their workflows and ensure the right resources are allocated to the right tasks.

  • Incident Management: Focuses on restoring services as quickly as possible to minimize impact on business operations. This includes identifying, diagnosing, and resolving issues that occur unexpectedly.
  • Request Fulfillment: Focuses on delivering user requests in a standardized way. Service requests are often pre-approved and have defined workflows, which make them simpler and quicker to handle.

By following ITIL guidelines, organizations can optimize both incident and service request management, improving response times, user satisfaction, and overall service quality.

Conclusion

While both incidents and service requests are integral parts of IT service management, they serve different purposes. Understanding the difference is crucial for maintaining operational efficiency and ensuring that IT resources are effectively utilized. Incidents are unexpected disruptions, while service requests are planned, routine requests for service or information. Proper classification of these two categories in ITIL helps organizations respond appropriately to both, ultimately improving service quality and user satisfaction.

By clearly distinguishing between incidents and service requests, you can streamline your IT support processes, reduce operational overhead, and improve the overall efficiency of your service desk.

‍